My search led me to a seller who had an antique French mirror circa 1880 that they bought at the Paris Flea Market. They had it listed for a great price and the seller lived about 4 blocks from my house. All the stars had aligned.
We need to figure out a way to secure it to the wall but that will have to wait until I can get help - I can't even adjust the placement of it it's so heavy!
Yay for change!